How one kind of cheese destroyed who I am
Op/Ed Editor Brian Sheridan shares his experience with Beer Kaese cheese and why we should remove it
More stories from Brian Sheridan
As a Wisconsinite, I have grown up surrounded by a plethora of cheeses from all makes and backgrounds. I consider myself a cheese enthusiast and am open to trying different varieties.
I have my favorites, as well as some I’d be okay with never trying again. Up until recently, I’ve never been emotionally traumatized through the consumption of dairy products. I love cheese and it has (mostly) loved me back.
Then I found it. The most heinous of creations. A cheese brewed and concocted most likely through arcane and demonic rituals meant to destroy the very fabrics of a human’s existence through even the tiniest of morsels from its brick. It’s called Beer Kaese.
Beer kaese, or beer cheese, is a plague on our precious dairy community here in Wisconsin. It brings shame to the meaning of cheese. Experts may call it “unique” in flavor or “earthy.” This does not begin to describe the experience of eating Beer Kaese.
I recently held a cheese party, probably the most Wisconsin-like thing I’ve ever done in my life. A few friends and I bought 23 different kinds of cheeses and taste-tested them while giving them a rating of 1-10. One of those was Beer Kaese because it sounded fun and adventurous. Oh, how naive we were.
The sampling went well and I got to try all different kinds of cheeses I never would have thought about. We found a blueberry cheese and a walnut fudge cheese that were surprisingly better than most cheeses we purchased.
Most of the smoked cheeses we bought were disappointing, which caught me off guard. Some were very unique, like the Mediterranean cheddar, while others were dull and I’ve already forgotten about.
Near the end of the list we had the ones we were hesitant about, like Limburger, brie and the cheese that changed who I am as a person.
Finally, it came time to cut open the Beer Kaese. One common characteristic of cheese is that they can be quite fragrant. Some may put it mildly and say this particular cheese was “pungent.” These words do not begin to describe Beer Kaese.
The closest thing I can compare the smell to is a combination of wet garbage and rotting bowels. The scent was enough to make you heave and regret all your decisions involving Beer Kaese.
As someone who has muscled through smelly cheeses in the past, there’s often a more pleasant taste than what the smell leads you to believe. This was not the case.
As soon as the chunk of cheese entered my mouth, I knew my childhood was dead. I would never feel the same again. My tongue recoiled in disgust and I had to heave it out of my mouth.
Most of us reflexively spat it out, as you instinctively do with most poisons. A couple pushed through the tears and gagging to accomplish the feat of swallowing this atrocity.
You would think this ends here, where we pack up the cheese and be done with it. Beer Kaese is not that forgiving. The smell lingered in the entire house. There was no where you could go without smelling death. It was in the air, on your fingers and in your mouth.
We all changed that day. Where we were once laughing, light-hearted folks, we quickly became husks of our former selves.
This is not a product meant for cheese parties. This is an abomination to cheese everywhere. This is not something worthy of being associated with Wisconsin. We should not stand for the distribution of this product in grocery stores around the state.
As survivors of this catastrophe, A petition on change.org has been started by us to remove all traces of Beer Kaese from the earth. We must put a stop to its production before it not only ruins the lives of bright, healthy citizens, but contaminates our air and water supply and sends our society into chaos.
Do your duty as a productive member of this cheesy community and help stop this creation from ever harming another innocent life. Stand up. Help make the world a better place.
Christine • Jul 8, 2024 at 10:44 am
Such a funny article.! We call Baer Kase cheese, “fart in a bag!”..but we love the taste. The initial first smell makes some people gag, but on the perfect cracker like Wheat Thins, it is Delicious!
Christine , from Minnesota
Dave • Jun 8, 2024 at 2:18 am
Is this a serious post? I guess everyone could have wildly different tastes but your description leads me to believe that all “beer cheeses” are not even made the same.
I have only experienced it a couple times over one weekend (while on a week-long vacation in Austria). We were warned of the smell and actually banned from entering the home until the meal was ready; a culturally common policy for most males coming home from work in the region (historically common but still somewhat prevalent to this day). So much so that the location outside of the home where “the men” would socialize while waiting for dinner was called “the man shed” and it was decided by my cohorts that I needed to build one in my back yard once I returned to the states, 😂🤣.
Then they took me to Oktoberfest but the point being that the cheese tasted absolutely nothing like how it smelled and was seemingly viewed as a delicacy from what I could gather (and taste!).
used to love cheese • Mar 26, 2024 at 5:13 pm
Five minutes ago, I just ate Beer Kaese cheese for the first time ever. I will be 50 in 12 days… this is the first cheese I ever met that I was repulsed by. Never thought I would hate a cheese so much.
Wendi • Aug 31, 2022 at 7:04 am
OMG, this is the truth! Tried this last night for the first time – spat it out and threw the rest away. Cheese is my favorite food, but I couldn’t even gag down one bight of this nastiness!
Cheryl • Aug 19, 2022 at 9:35 pm
🤣🤣🤣🤣
My thoughts and feelings exactly!!!
My husband loves the stuff. …WHY???
Rafael • Jul 16, 2022 at 10:12 pm
Nah, beer Kaese is the best. In my opinion. I love it.
Christa Bick • Sep 12, 2024 at 12:36 pm
Reading the comments….I am confused. What everyone is describing is not the bier kaese that I am familiar with and wish that I could find! Bier kaese does not start off as a pungent cheese…..it takes a few weeks to become pungent. That is when it is at its best!
A. Sterner • Nov 6, 2021 at 7:13 pm
Ain’t it wonderful! Give me a block of it with some coarse ground mustard and I am in love.
Cheeso • Dec 27, 2020 at 4:18 am
It’s great I can’t get enough of it I have found that it can be addictive
Ron Abels • Oct 16, 2020 at 12:50 pm
Lots of chuckles out of the article but I disagree with how good this tatses. To a guy that grew up around Limburger for years this cheese was so mild tasting.
Slice up some pieces and throw on slices of bread with raw onion slices and some brown mustard and have a beer for tracer IS
PARAMOUNT.
I’ve been looking for some locally in Pittsburgh so maybe they are taking it off the market but I will buy some somewhere soon./
Ron “Moose” Abels
Marc Rindels • Sep 15, 2020 at 1:00 pm
Great memories of my Dad eating Beer Kaese on saltines and us kids running howling in annoyance from the smell…. let’s call that smell what it is… toe-jam.
Last I saw it was at Burnett Creamery on Hwy 70 just east of Grantsburg, WI.
Good luck!
Norman Czerski • Jul 31, 2020 at 11:36 pm
There is a German cheese, I do not recall the name, that could gag a dog off a gut pile. It was commonly referred to, in Germany, as “stink foot cheese”. This must be the cheese you refer to as I have experienced it. Beer Kaese is not the same cheese. Although having a slightly musty smell, Beer Kaese has a flavor similar to blue cheese although smoother and somehow an order of magnitude more satisfying. The greatest testament to the desirability of Beer Kaese cheese is that when I was able to obtain it, I live in Alaska, it was being stolen. I hate a thief and even more the ones that will steal cheese.
JP Coetzee • May 25, 2020 at 6:21 pm
Personally i do agree its not for everyone but i do love it as a cheese lover and have eaten cheeses all over the world and i still do love this 1… yes the smell is like rotten feet but the taste is not as bad as u describe…
Brian Pooler • Apr 29, 2020 at 10:28 pm
Thank you for the entertaining and humorous article. As some enlightened cheese connoisseurs have noted, there is nothing better that a wedge of smear brick or bier kase. It is true that the cheese’s bouquet is quite enlightening and fragrant. It is also true that paired with the appropriate complimentary beer, rye bread, crackers or slice of onion this cheese is unquestionably palate pleasing. Albeit true that this cheese, when aged, does share a bouquet similar to that of a diaper pale or stinky feet. However, this cheese has a unique reputation of making its presence known by, reaching out and grabbing one by the nose and Say: Here I AM. You are in for a Delicious Treat! As a member of the family who founded the Chalet Cheese Coop, in Monroe WI, I have had the pleasure and honor of working in the only cheese factory in the United States that produces this unique and prestigious member of the aromatic and robust cheese family. This factory is not only known for producing notably delectable and palate pleasing delights, it is also the origin of some of the greatest master cheese makers in the country.
Clem Kost • Mar 27, 2020 at 3:36 pm
I’m 78 years old and 2nd generation American with both parents born in Germany. Living in the New York/New Jersey area I grew up eating and loving Bier Kase. It was really stinky but the taste was smooth, biting, velvety and delicious. Now, retired I live in S C and my younger brother in FL. He recently ordered 4 LBS. of Beer Kaese (notice the different spelling). Neither of us has had the cheese in years and were anxiously looking forward to a cocktail hour around the pool with our room temperature cheese. We unwrapped the packaging. The familiar silver wrapping around an ivory-colored cheese looked inviting. As we sat by the poolside we were waiting for the pungent aroma to arrive. It didn’t. We then decided to taste the cheese that we grew up to love. Simultaneously, while looking at each other with a question mark written all over our face, we exclaimed there is something missing. No stinky aroma; no biting taste. Matter of fact very little taste. I would rather consume a very ripe Cambambert as opposed to this knock off of the original Bier Kase. While the wrapper is similar to the original wrapping we noticed the words “beer cheese” and “Beer Kaese” were written on the wrapper to look like the original which only had Bier Kase written on the wrapper. This is NOT the same Bier Kase I grew up with. This is an imitation thereof. I suspect the original culture was lost just like Borden’s lost the culture to Liederkranz (another great tasting cheese). Those that are marketing the current Beer Kaese as the original and charging as much as $14.00 per pound should be ashamed of themselves. This a fraud to sell this as the original Bier Kase.
Jeebus • Nov 29, 2019 at 8:47 pm
Bierkase is delicious, you cray.
Carol Mulhall • Nov 2, 2019 at 2:01 pm
I being from Wisconsin , now in South Carolina order this cheese. I love it. Maybe you need to eat it on a slice of rye bread, then the cheese and optional slice of red onion and of. course a beer. Nothing better. Now I have to have it shipped to me in cooler months.
Jack Kober • Aug 21, 2019 at 4:49 pm
I grew up in Wisconsin in the Sheboygan area. In my teens I worked in a grocery store with a service counter. Customers would ask for a sample of cheeses and of course we would let them sample. We sold thousands of pounds of cheese. Everything from squeaky fresh Colby to 5 year old longhorn cheddar. Yes we sold the mild brick cheeses and also the aged brick cheeses. That’s where I acquired a taste for the aged cheeses. Widmer Cheese Factory in Theresa makes a wonderful mild and medium aged brick cheese. Beerkaese can get to be pretty strong tasting if has been sitting on the grocers case for to long. The best is to buy it at a cheese store that sells a lot of cheese.
Marsh • Jul 31, 2019 at 3:37 pm
Hysterical (albeit accurate) article! I grew up with this cheese buried in my dad’s basement beer fridge and learned to love it on saltines or Ritz crackers. Definitely hard to find these days but can be ordered online. Thanks for sharing!
N Knudtson • Apr 19, 2019 at 4:50 pm
I found this article while attempting to purchase BC cheese online from Montana. It tastes even better if you age it longer. Cut it with gloves on wax paper, let it hit room temperature, enjoy on a flat cracker. NOM! Don’t smell it, taste it!
Levi Hilton • Dec 10, 2018 at 11:09 pm
It is definitely an acquired taste, one that has been handed down by generations as a Christmas tradition, my father ate it on Christmas, his father ate it, and I’m sure his father did too…and I’ve successfully passed it on to my youngest now! While I agree it is most avoidable to get on yer fingers (can’t get the smell off…like the toilet paper ripped when wiping ;), served on a saltine with salami and honey mustard, there isn’t a better tasting cheese out there! Can’t wait for Christmas! lol
bill mulholland • Jul 26, 2018 at 6:55 pm
lol, I recall as a child, my Dad’s fondness for Beer Kaese cheese. We simply called it “stinky cheese”, and avoided it. However, it must be a taste that appeals to adults, maybe, as I, on a road trip from Wisconsin to Las Vegas, decided to bring a cooler of foods to eat at road stops along the way. Well, foods included some good rye bread, liverwurst, Usinger’s summer sausage, and a block of Beer Kaese cheese. Despite it’s reputation, the cheese was surprisingly tasty on a sandwich at road stop picnic areas, and we really did enjoy it. Now,I’m trying to find Beer Kaese cheese here in Las Vegas, so far, without success, sigh. I know it sounds like I must be crazy, but it was good on our sandwiches.
Jens Kjaer • Jun 21, 2018 at 6:59 pm
You must have succeeded in you quest to remove it from the store shelves. I can no longer find it anywhere. I’m going through Beer Kaese withdraws. As a Dane who grew up with Beer Kaese in our diet, not only do I love it on fresh pumpernickel but, the stuff works great at keeping friends out of my refrigerator.
Wendy Minshall • Jun 13, 2018 at 9:57 pm
This made me laugh and cry at the same time. I’m not even from Wisconsin. But, we have this place… Osceola Cheese Factory. It had the word ‘beer’ in it, so I thought my college-aged son would like it. We opened it. It smelled of butt. But we tasted it anyway. Why would we TASTE something that smelled that bad. What were we thinking? What is wrong with us? (and the taste won’t come off of my tongue)
William Giebel • May 23, 2018 at 5:09 pm
My grandfather ate that cheese regularly when I was young. He called it brau kaese. I couldn’t get past the foul, reeking smell of it, however he got me to try it once & in my imagination, it tasted like something that someone packaged after processing some cow pies.
Cheryl Pettigrew • Nov 7, 2017 at 10:55 am
You had me rolling in laughter. My grandma was the daughter of Swiss immigrants from Flasch (canton of Graubünden).
I grew up with a chunk of bierkäse in the fridge.
Apparently the taste must either be inherited via DNA or acquired by effort.
Assuming my DNA switch was in the on position during cheese appreciation day I have always loved it.
I confess to one foul experience though. I had the misfortune of getting some that was overly ripe. The ammoniation had jumped the shark and far exceeded the the floral quality of a forgotten diaper pail.
If you can muster the courage to try it again get it young and have it with slices of granny Smith apple.
Jennifer from Minnesota • Oct 12, 2017 at 7:51 pm
oh god. agree. I count myself an equal opportunity cheese lover – brie, gouda, blue, limburger – I love them all. Just tasted some of this and thought, what the heck? I, like you, have been transformed in the worst way. I googled to see if anyone else had a similar reaction and found your article. Funny but just a little too close to home. Death to beer kaese
William Giebel • May 23, 2018 at 5:15 pm
I agree with your sentiments. Thought my grandfather had accidentally poisoned me, back in the ‘60’s, when he got me to try some of his- he ate it regularly.